Nutter, We Said it Before and We’ll Say it Again, No Police/ICE Collaboration
On Friday, December 11th Mayor Nutter’s administration released their proposed changes to the city’s ICE hold executive order, a historic win in separating the Poli-Migra.
The immigrant community, immigrant rights organizations and advocates have been clear for weeks that any city collaboration with ICE is unacceptable. We must stand against any use of city resources that will lead to the deportation of our community.
Read the Philadelphia Family Unity Network’s full response below.
Hon. Mayor Michael Nutter
Philadelphia PA 19107
Dear Mayor Nutter,
We are writing in response to the draft Executive Order provided to us by your administration which would rescind and replace Executive Order No. 1-14 (“Policy Regarding U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency Detainer requests”). Our concerns are not swayed by our review of this draft. We urge you again not to make any changes to your position on this issue, and to let the original order stand, in response to the unanimous call to do so.
We understand from our meeting with Deputy Mayor Gillison that your administration anticipates the number of individuals who would be subjected to this revised policy to be relatively small, and that your position is that communicating with Immigration and Customs Enforcement in these situations will contribute to public safety. However, this reasoning ignores the experiences of thousands of Philadelphia families that have been ripped apart by the deportation machine and made to feel unsafe and unstable in their own homes and communities because of the activities of ICE.
If your administration believes that the criminal legal system in Philadelphia is capable of adjudicating criminal matters, we see no reason why Philadelphia should participate in the practice of singling out certain individuals for additional punishment with permanent consequences simply due to their immigration status. This change in your policy also contradicts your position on the value of reentry and rehabilitation for returning citizens and instead forces these individuals to be permanently exiled from their families and communities. We know you value re-entry and second chances as illustrated by your signing of a comprehensive Ban the Box policy just yesterday at City Hall. With this in mind, we strongly oppose any revision to the existing order that allows city employees to report Philadelphia residents to Immigration and Customs Enforcement, full stop.
The additional provisions in this order do not allay our concerns for several reasons. While we appreciate the intention behind the creation of an advisory board, we disagree that the goal of any advisory committee on this issue should be to promote dialogue with federal immigration officials. As we have explained in detail through our previous communication, outreach materials, press conferences and in numerous meetings with your administration and previous Mayors over the past decade, the Department of Homeland Security has traumatized Philadelphia’s immigrant communities through brutal, racist practices that have destroyed families and disrupted community stability with impunity. If your office would like to create an avenue for community input on issues related to law enforcement in immigrant communities, we suggest that you start by convening community forums to solicit input on city policies related to immigration from those directly affected by those policies.
We know from experience that local efforts to address abuse at the hands of ICE will be fruitless without accountability at the federal level. This lack of accountability is a core piece of why we believe that any local participation in the deportation system should be prohibited. With regard to your request for DHS to create a hotline to accept complaints, we are unclear as to why community members would report abuse at the hands of the Department of Homeland Security to the agency which is committing the abuse. DHS currently operates several avenues where problems may be reported, none of which are effective in actually addressing concerns. Public relations efforts, such as the “public advocate” position previously created by ICE, are not effective in facilitating dialogue for the reasons described above. We do of course applaud the request for data, as ICE has been notoriously reluctant to provide information on its activities, however we don’t see why you could not obtain this information through other channels that would not require a revision of the existing Executive Order.
In accordance with the concerns raised above and in direct response to the needs and experiences of the communities we serve, if your administration insists on replacing the previous Executive Order, we call on your administration to make the following changes in place of your proposal:
- Enhance community safety and trust in city agencies by prohibiting the Department of Homeland Security from using city property and resources, including physical space in police districts and prisons, to interrogate Philadelphia residents and enforce civil immigration laws;
- Conserve city resources by prohibiting city employees, including police and prison staff, from communicating with the Department of Homeland Security to facilitate the deportation of Philadelphia residents.
The Philadelphia Family Unity Network
The Philadelphia Family United Network members include 1Love Movement, Juntos, New Sanctuary Movement of Philadelphia, the Pennsylvania Immigration and Citizenship Coalition and Victim/Witness Services of South Philadelphia.